Reviewer Guidelines
Standards for rigorous and constructive peer review in lactation science.
The Foundation of Breastfeeding Science Quality
Peer review is the cornerstone of credible lactation research. Your expert evaluation ensures published work meets the highest standards of scientific validity and clinical relevance.
Timeliness
Complete reviews within 14 days of acceptance. Lactation researchers value rapid publication—notify the editor promptly if unable to meet deadlines.
Objectivity
Evaluate manuscripts based solely on scientific and clinical merit. Provide evidence-based critique without personal bias.
Confidentiality
Treat manuscripts as confidential. Never share findings, discuss content, or use ideas without author permission.
Constructiveness
Offer actionable suggestions for improvement. Even for rejections, provide feedback helping authors strengthen research.
- Summary: Brief overview of the study and lactation science contribution
- Major Comments: Methodological concerns, validity issues, fundamental flaws
- Minor Comments: Clarity issues, statistical refinements, figure improvements
- Recommendation: Accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject
Questions About Reviewing?
Contact the editorial office for guidance.
